National Trust attempts to block £100m Giant's Causeway golf course

Campaigning group challenges Donald Trump-style plan backed by Northern Irish politicians for five-star resort on world heritage site

• Jamie Doward
• The Observer, Saturday 29 December 2012 23.25 GMT
• Jump to comments (77)

The National Trust is against plans for a golf course at the edge of the Giant's Causeway in Northern Ireland. Photograph: Paul Faith/PA

Conflict is synonymous with the Giant's Causeway. Children in Northern Ireland are weaned on the legend of how its rugged landscape was formed when the giant Finn MacCool confronted his Scottish rival, Fingal, by hurling rocks into the sea.

A more prosaic, but no less violent, explanation for the causeway's genesis attributes the creation of its 39,000 hexagonal, basalt stones to a series of volcanic eruptions 60m years ago.

Now the causeway is at the centre of conflict again. The National Trust, one of the UK's most formidable campaigning organisations, is seeking to thwart the development of a £100m golf course on the edge of the causeway, Northern Ireland's only Unesco world heritage site.

The trust, which is charged with protecting the site, is using a judicial review to challenge the Northern Ireland government's decision to grant planning permission to a five-star resort that will boast a clubhouse, 120-bedroom hotel and 75 guest suites.

With its potential to create hundreds of jobs, many see the development of the Bushmills Dunes golf course as a major regeneration project. But the trust disagrees, on the grounds that the course, which would be 500 metres from the causeway, lies within a "buffer zone" that Unesco, the UN's heritage watchdog, says must be protected.

Now the looming legal row, which is due to commence on 9 January, could become a defining event for Northern Ireland, one that says much about how it sees itself.

Hundreds of thousands of visitors pour on to the causeway each year to marvel not only at the site, but at its breathtaking views all the way down to Donegal and over to Scotland's Mull of Kintyre, 16 miles away. One enthusiastic visitor was the prime minister, David Cameron, who went during the Olympics and talked of how tourism could help to secure Northern Ireland's prosperity.

But how this vision is to be realised lies at the heart of the row, one that will have consequences not just for the causeway but, potentially, for the UK's other 27 Unesco-listed sites.

After the opening of the acclaimed Titanic Belfast centre in the spring, the row over the right to fly unionist flags has given an ugly, sectarian turn to the end of the year, and now Northern Ireland stands at a crossroads. In its past it sees a poor country blighted by the Troubles, but rich in history, folklore and natural beauty. In its future, it sees potential to become a modern nation exemplified by the success of its golfers, including 2011 Open champion Darren Clarke and the current world No 1, Rory McIlroy.

These two, along with former US Open winner Graeme McDowell, have done much to put Northern Ireland on the golfing world's map. But Bushmills Dunes, say its supporters, would take the country into a different league. Alistair Hanna, the New York-based developer behind the scheme, talks passionately about its potential to make Northern Ireland the "gold standard" in links golf. The course's designer, David McLay Kidd, has promised Hanna: "If I can't get your course into the top 50 of the world, you should shoot me."

The development would see a desolate place of dunes and scrub that looks out to where the North Atlantic melds with the Irish Sea replaced by lush greens and a labour-intensive landscape, at odds with the natural environment. James Orr, of Friends of the Earth, has likened the development to "a drive-through burger bar at the Taj Mahal".

Inevitably, parallels have been drawn with the controversy that surrounded Donald Trump's £750m golf resort in Aberdeenshire, with Hanna playing the part of the unloved US billionaire. But the comparisons with Trump can be overblown. A former McKinsey consultant and Harvard graduate, Hanna was born in Northern Ireland and has many friends in the province, which he still visits regularly.

The majority of local politicians and businessmen seem to be behind the plan. Ian Paisley Jr, a Democratic Unionist MP, described the trust's opposition as a "disgrace to Northern Ireland". Golfers are also supportive. Clarke has attacked the trust for trying to block a project that he said would create 360 jobs for the local economy.

Paisley claims that the row has already prompted one potential financial backer to look elsewhere.

The trust, which has four million members around the world, is acutely aware that its decision to take legal action is controversial and almost unprecedented. But Heather Thompson, National Trust director for Northern Ireland, claims the trust had no choice: to walk away from the fight would have been a betrayal of its core beliefs and detrimental to the long-term success of Northern Ireland.

"This issue is wider than about Ireland and even the UK," she said. "It's about how we use the resources we have today to ensure future generations have similar opportunities."

In a letter to the trust's 60,000 members in Northern Ireland, she explained: "We passionately believe that such a development in this protected landscape is wrong – once it's gone, it's gone. If this development is allowed to proceed in this special place, then the message is being dispatched that nowhere in Northern Ireland, no matter how special or protected, is safe from development."

Unsurprisingly Hanna, an evangelical Christian, has been critical of the trust's actions. "Those who instigate judicial reviews cost taxpayers money and slow down development, despite knowing the process can't improve the decision," he said on Twitter.

Northern Ireland's environment minister, Alex Attwood, has argued that the tensions between economic development and respect for landscape can be resolved. Approving Bushmills Dunes, he said it would "be accompanied by stringent conditions which will mitigate the impacts of the development on the ecology of the site and the local landscape".

But doubts linger. Northern Ireland already has more than 80 golf courses. Several are in administration and others have declining memberships. The new development would be adjacent to a nine-hole course and only a few miles from neighbouring Royal Portrush golf club, where the Irish Open took place this summer.

Critics say that Northern Ireland has learned nothing from the painful lessons of its over-reaching southern neighbour. The "Celtic tiger's" building boom saw a glut of luxury developments, but the ensuing bust has left many lying empty.

However, their opponents say the problem is not over-development, but lack of development. The economy in Northern Ireland is flatlining and jobs are scarce. Last month Patton Group, one of Northern Ireland's oldest construction firms, called in the administrators. Samson and Goliath, the massive cranes operated by Belfast's famous shipbuilder, Harland & Wolff, are in danger of becoming little more than tourist attractions as the global economic turmoil continues. And despite Cameron's hopes for a tourism bonanza, the number of people visiting the country fell by almost 12% this year, an alarming drop given the substantial PR campaign that was employed to draw people in during the Olympics.

At a time when Northern Ireland desperately needs good economic news, many hope it will find salvation in its fairways. The trust, by contrast, fears the seductive arguments of golf mania could result in the country failing to protect its most valuable asset. The irony is not lost on Thompson. "We've spent so much time fighting over the land," she said. "We really need to look after it."